From Lab to Laptop:

are Preprints disrupting the traditional peer review process?

Ah, the traditional academic peer review process. The thing that strikes fear into the hearts of many academics, and yet is so crucial to the integrity of scholarly publishing. For years, the traditional peer review process has been the gold standard for ensuring the quality of research that gets published in academic journals.

But in recent years, preprint servers have been gaining popularity, and with them comes the question: are they disrupting the traditional peer review process? Or perhaps the traditional peer review process needed disrupting.

First, let’s clarify what preprint servers are. Essentially, they are platforms where researchers can upload their manuscripts before they have been peer reviewed and published in a traditional academic journal. This allows other researchers to read and comment on the manuscript before it is officially published, and can provide valuable feedback to the author. 

So, are preprint servers disrupting the traditional peer-review process? Well, it depends on who you ask. Some argue that preprint servers are democratizing science by allowing anyone to read and comment on research before it is published. 

Traditionally academic research has been the exclusive undertaking of the upper echelons of society, this has changed in recent years, and preprint servers go further by allowing greater access to research at an earlier stage in the process. However, others argue that preprint servers are undermining the peer-review process by allowing unvetted research to be disseminated. 

With any democracy there are problems; anyone can have free speech, but it doesn’t necessarily mean they have something valid or meaningful to say. And it’s the same with preprints. With no validation process, any old junk can, in theory, be thrown up onto a preprint server.  

A key benefit of preprint servers is that they make research more accessible (and we all know I love a bit of Open Access).

No more expensive journals that only a select few articles for publication (only “high-impact” articles of course), which the lay public can’t afford to read. With preprint servers, anyone and everyone can access the latest research without breaking the bank. Score one for the little guy! 

One of the biggest concerns around preprint servers is the potential for bogus research to be shared widely, leading to misinformation and confusion. After all, just because something is posted on a preprint server, doesn’t mean it is accurate or reliable. Some would argue that the same can be said about journals, but with preprint servers, taking things with a grain of salt goes a long way. Is there the potential that pre-print servers could lead to a flood of unverified information that could be harmful to the public? Yes, absolutely. Is there also the potential to educate the public to recognise validated sources of research compared to unvalidated sources? Also true. But which will happen first, I’ll leave that to your imagination. 

Cheerleaders for preprint servers argue that they are actually improving the peer review process. By allowing more people to read and comment on research before it is published, preprint servers can help to catch errors, identify flaws in methodology, and generally improve the quality of research before it’s even submitted to a journal. It’s like crowd-sourcing the review process. And who doesn’t love a little crowd-sourcing? 

Overall, the rise of preprint servers is both exciting and a little bit scary. One thing’s for sure, preprint servers are shaking things up in the academic world. While they have the potential to democratize science and improve the quality of research, they also pose risks if non-peer reviewed research is shared widely. On the whole, I am optimistic, bring on the disruption! I’ll certainly be keeping a close eye on preprint servers to see how they impact the peer review process and academic publishing as a whole. Stay tuned! 

Share Post

I hope you found this blog post helpful and interesting. Make sure you subscribe to MugsPubs to receive notifications in your inbox and keep up-to-date with the latest posts and developments.

You can also contact me on LinkedIn and tell me what you would like to see in my next blog post!

To support this blog, show us some love and click on the Subscribe button to keep up to date with my latest posts.